Pages of My Life – Elsie McKenney

Pages of My Life

How to Escape the Writer’s Cage

Have you ever sat at your desk, fingers dashing over the keyboard, looking completely carefree to those around you? But something invisible kept you trapped. Afraid. That cage can seem productive, even fulfilling, for writers. You keep track of your word count, edit your sentences until they gleam, and meet your deadlines.

Yet a trickle of fear nips at your conscious, deciding what you write, who you attempt to impress, and how much of your true self you let readers see.

For years, I lived in a cage built on a foundation of lies, controlled by shame and guarded by fear. Inside a controlling religious group, I mistook fear for faith, silence for holiness, and performance for love. I measured every step by one anxious question: What will happen if I don’t get this right?

At nineteen I finally recognized the bondage I lived in. Jesus met me in places no one else could see. He exposed lies, taught me to recognize His voice, and showed me that a familiar cage is not a permanent home.

But my journey did not end when I escaped the cult. Learning to live in freedom took time and became a journey of its own. Years passed by and I kept my past a secret until it revealed itself in night terrors. I finally found relief in writing down my story, and it morphed into a novel. But I only told a few people about my endeavor. Fear of rejection became another prison without bars I found myself trapped in.

Your cage may have a different name than mine. Perfectionism, comparison, or the nagging thought that you will never succeed. Maybe you live in fear of failure. Failure to finish the next draft. Failur to earn the next five-star review.

First Peter 2:9 describes God calling His people out of darkness. But it doesn’t stop there. He calls us into His wonderful light. That invitation reaches into our writing lives too. We do not have to stay in the writer’s cage, earning our identity through a huge platform, publishing a bestseller, or reaching a thousand reviews on Amazon.

Here is the framework I construct to step out of the cage and write from freedom instead of fear.

Name It: Name the Lie

Before we can challenge an invisible cage, we need to understand what holds it together. The lie that kept me in my cage was the idea that I had to get everything right. One misstep meant I had failed not only my family and leaders. I failed God.

As writers, our version might sound like this: If my manuscript is rejected, I am a failure. If readers disagree with my opinion, I should stay silent. My story is ordinary so it doesn’t matter.

Second Corinthians 10:5 calls us to bring our thoughts under control, under the obedience of Christ. This first step involves writing down the beliefs that shape our choices. Then asking whether it reflects God’s truth or fear’s prediction. Rejection can only tell us that we need to work on our submission. It cannot tell us who we are.

The question is not, “Am I without fear?” It is, “What does it look like to be a faithful writer today?” Elsie McKenney on Pages of My Life. Share on X

Face It: Face the Fear

I once assured a friend I could dye her hair because the instructions seemed simple enough and included pictures. How hard could it be? But the sun-kissed blonde look she had hoped for turned out to be a dramatic shade of traffic-cone orange.

My stomach dropped. Before she said anything, my emotions spiraled because fear had supplied the ending to our story. The voice in my head shouted: You ruined everything. She will not want a friend like you.

Much to my amazement, the next week, she arrived at my door sporting that bright orange hair and a forgiving smile. “It’s just hair,” she said. “It will grow out.” We laughed. Grace rewrote the ending fear had predicted.

I had wanted to run and hide—from my friend and the whole situation. But because I wanted to keep the relationship, I had to own up to my blunder and make an apology. The lesson I learned that day was not that mistakes do not matter. It was that mistakes do not define my identity.

Writers face similar moments after an awkward pitch, disappointing critique, or an unresponsive lead to publication. Fear predicts rejection and keeps us trapped in its cage. But courage unlocks the door. Lets us listen, understand, edit, and rewrite our masterpiece.

Leave It: Practice Freedom

Galatians 5:1 encourages us to stand firm in the freedom Christ has already given us. However, freedom is more than recognizing an invisible cage. It is living differently outside of it. Instead of basing our identity on the approval of others, the performance of our books, or other people’s opinion, we ground our identity in Christ.

My healing grew slowly, like sunlight trickling into a winter morning. Jesus was patient when I doubted or could only take one small step forward until I could trust again. Even now, when I feel I may falter, I am encouraged by other writers. I especially love Elisabeth Elliot’s words: “Sometimes when we are called to obey, the fear does not subside and we are expected to move against the fear. One must choose to do it afraid.”

Before your next writing session try this:

  • Name it: Name the lie that’s keeping you silent.
  • Face it: Face the fear by replacing the lie with a biblical truth. Read it before opening your manuscript.
  • Leave it: Practice freedom daily: draft that difficult paragraph you’ve been avoiding, ask a friend for feedback, or submit the book proposal you’ve tucked into the drawer.

The question is not, “Am I without fear?” It is, “What does it look like to be a faithful writer today?” Your cage may feel familiar, but it is not your home.

Choose to write afraid.

Elsie McKenney

Meet Elsie

Elsie McKenney is an award-winning novelist, keynote speaker, and writing instructor who helps writers tell stories that reveal truth, inspire hope, and cultivate resilient faith.

Learn more at her website or BRRC Author Profile Page.

The Conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

No Comments